Monday, 9 July 2007

On Certainty

The levels of certainty.


Allah who knows the seen and the unseen proclaims that the Quran revealed to the Holy Prophet is the truth of assured certainty (haqqul yaqin), which can never be disproved.
* * *

Truth as understood by man by the application of his power of judgement and appraisement of visible evidence through reasoning or inference is called ilmul yaqin.

* *

If he sees something with his own eyes, described as "seeing is believing", it is called Ayn ul yaqin which sometimes terminates in delusion or deception.

*
tafsir 69:38 --from here

* * *

"Argue with a fool, and most likely the fool is doing the same... because the problem is not, do you believe what you see, but what is it that you see?"
-- reproduced, with thanks

2 comments:

Unknown said...

oh and also: seeing is believing :)

blizs/ful said...

salam,

I just skimmed past this again, it has been a long time, hasnt it? I just wanted to mention, the shia hold that the ascension (me'raj) was physical as well as spiritual: the Prophet (saw) ascended many many times spiritually, but the me'raj was a complete ascension of body and soul. The Quran refers to the event in surat al Isra I believe saying that Glory is to Allah who took His servant (abd) from the sacred mosque to the farthest mosque: here it states in tafsir that the word abd implies the whole human being, not just the spirit. There is an essay you can read which summarises the arguments for a physical ascension, on our community website: http://www.al-rasool.co.uk/ahlulbayt/Meraj.pdf

with salam.